To Retain Or Not To Retain: A Seasonal Question

Every year, parents of children who are not quite meeting grade-based standards are faced with the dilemma of choosing to hold their child back or promote them on to the next grade. School districts often have one set of perspectives while parents have another. With No Child Left Behind, a greater number of children are being retained, despite consistent research that demonstrates the lack of evidence to support the effectiveness of repeating a grade. Although some students may initially demonstrate academic improvement, over time, those “gains” are not maintained and in fact, it would seem that they often perform worse when compared to similar students who were not retained. The negative effects of grade retention range from poor social adjustment and difficulty with peer relationships to a higher high school dropout rate compared with other groups and often, long-term problems with adjustment, employment and at risk behavior.

Rather than hope that a second round of the same curriculum will produce the desired effect, alternative, evidence-based interventions that will enhance students’ competence across the spectrum of skills are needed. There are workgroups in a number of the schools of education who are actively working on programs targeted towards improving the performance and experience of low-achieving students. A number of key features have been identified, including parent involvement, culturally-sensitive outreach, tutoring and individual enrichment strategies, systematic assessment, school-based mental health, multidisciplinary student support teams, mentoring programs, extended school year and extended days, better integration of all education programs within a school site and opportunities for all stakeholders to play a role in creating an environment where each student experiences success.

Still Have Questions?

Contact Us For A Free Consultation

Whether you are looking for multi-sensory math tutoring, executive functions coaching, or want to learn about your student's learning strengths and challenges, QWERTY is here to help.

Contact QWERTY »

Want to Read More?

More Articles That May Interest You:

3 Reasons Kids Struggle With Math And Our Ways To Help

We recently read a blog post titled “3 Reasons Kids Struggle With Math And How To Help.” We’re taking a... Read more »

8 Strategies For Getting Instructions To Stick

Kids with ADHD have trouble focusing and sustaining attention, so while they may seem to understand the directions given in... Read more »

3(+1) Challenges We’ve Seen (and Solutions!) In Personalized Learning

A Change in the Teaching Model Educational pedagogy has seen a sizable shift toward attempting to personalize learning in the... Read more »

Social Emotional Learning (SEL) Happens

We introduced the importance of social emotional learning skills in a previous blog piece, 6 Ways to Jump Start Social... Read more »